Pre-Mattel Josefina's don't actually have the soft eyelashes. They don't have the current stiff ones either, they're kind of in between. PM Josies are worth more in theory, but so few people can tell the difference that I don't think they go for much more. If you get Marisol or Nellie or Elizabeth, you can compare them, and you'll see the difference in the cheekbones and chin.